Global Citizenship Education in national curricula.
This webinar, co-developed with the Global Education Time (GET) project, is the third in the new ANGEL Research to Policy Webinar Series

Guest blog by Professor Piero Dominici.
As the world becomes smaller and smaller, education has taken on a “global” tinge, as has the idea of a one-world citizenry. However, even speaking of global citizenship is a difficult enterprise, not only because the basic rights of citizens in many parts of the world today are not as yet recognized, but also because the tendency to consider citizenship solely from a judicial standpoint, as merely a matter of legal norms and rules, without considering genuine citizen participation, is becoming more and more prevalent even among countries that pride themselves on their democratic traditions. In fact, far from encouraging active participation, the almost universal condition of hyper-connection among the people of the world’s nations amounts to little more than simulation of participation. What is more, although lip service is given to the concept of the close correlation between access to quality education and a robust citizenship, the delegation of educational processes to technology has become hegemonic, in the belief that all problems can be solved by hyper-technical and hyper-technological systems, through the expertise of AI and its ubiquitous algorithms. It may therefore be premature to propose global education for a global citizenry without first rethinking educational processes and institutions themselves, in their original local and/or national communities, through a systemic, grass-roots participation, involving the Person behind each citizen, who must be given the educational instruments that empower them to be capable of critical thinking and aware of the indeterminacy and complexity of life.
The question, therefore, as generations living in the third millennium, is whether we can inhabit indeterminacy and cherish the relationships between living beings without trying futilely to control life through our devices. Can we accept unpredictability without trying to rationalize everything outside of our control as “black swans”? Can we look away from our screens long enough to see the emergence surging all around us?
Complex (living) systems, despite the obsolete and inadequate paradigms which propagate the fatal error of equating them with systems that are merely complicated (that is, artificial, mechanical systems), require us to adopt a socio-systemic, relational paradigm in order to learn to inhabit the intrinsic indeterminacy of human life and all other living systems, in which “black swans” and other unexpected events are understood to be connotative features of life and complexity. In fact, life itself is emergence; it is permanently relational, an infinite, non-linear sequence of dynamic processes.
Imagine a person who has only seen the sunrise through a screen, losing the visual subtlety of the more tenuous colors and the fleeting dynamics of the changing skyscape, forgetting the sensation of standing with two feet on the wetness of dew-sprinkled grass, lacking the tickling vibration of the sounds made by bees or birdsongs or waves or wind through the trees, the mixed fragrance of flowers, trees and freshly cut grass, the caress of the morning breeze on skin, and the waking taste of the morning air. Imagine this person believing that recorded (or simulated) images and background sounds, along with information available about the earth’s rotation, the distance from the sun, and the weather forecast can be equated to this experience.
The hegemonic paradigm of the hyper-technological civilization brings in its wake a series of grand illusions intimately linked to the possibility of marginalizing the Human, delegating our choices, responsibilities and even our educational processes to systems of artificial intelligence and interconnected technological devices, which seem capable of restoring certainties that are instead purely illusory: grand illusions of rationality, total control, predictability, measurability, and the elimination of error.
Never before has it been so crucial to break free of our cognitive and epistemological cages to realize that everything is interdependent and relational, that objects are systems rather than vice-versa, and even more, that what we think of as objects are themselves relations: everything is relationship.
A concept that is evidently very relevant to relationships is that of sharing. But what is meant today by the word “sharing”? The idea of sharing needs to recover its original, non-commercial meaning, while the concept of “knowledge sharing”, which should define communication, has become a slogan rather than the actual sharing of knowledge, and is therefore too limited to further inclusion or to shake up the age-old logics of control. In spite of the exponential growth of connective opportunities, in which information and knowledge have become the main resources, society is as yet unable to guarantee that these networks generate fully communicative relationships, based on symmetrical relationships and authentic sharing. The economistic paradigm must be questioned, keeping in mind, however, that the crisis is far from being solely economic.
Indubitably, it is also a crisis of democracy. So what exactly is that sloppy, undisciplined mess we call democracy, anyway? One good definition is that democracy is complexity: it is open dialectics, plurality of opinions, thoughts, cultures, and visions of society. Democracy is conflict, openness, order and chaos. “Connected citizens” will not suffice: what we need are citizens -- not vassals -- educated in critical thinking, complexity, liberty, and responsibility. Currently, the risk is that of building an illusory form of citizenship without citizens, through processes of "simulation of participation" in which social actors represent the weakest link: a simulation of participation that leads inevitably to a simulation of citizenship and ultimately, to a simulation of democracy.
Where does education come into this? Can education help us to build a society that experiences itself as a living organism, rather than a mechanism-society? Because we appear to be living through an overturn, in which culture evolution is conditioning biological evolution, we need more than ever to engage in wonder, fostering curiosity together with creativity, and stimulate the younger generations by introducing a truly multi-disciplinary approach in schools and universities, as humanistic and scientific cultures can no longer be kept separate.
If schools and universities are to rediscover their original functions as social elevators, if they are to succeed in inspiring a society that intends to eliminate inequality and asymmetry, they themselves must be the first to avoid the great mistake of delegating carte blanche to technology. Can we encourage students to choose their fields by asking themselves: “what is my passion?” rather than settling for a subject that they believe will ensure them a better income?
There is, today, a hegemonic tyranny of concreteness that continues to manifest itself in all areas of intellectual and cultural production, even scientific research, which have been reduced to one dimension, the apparently neutral and objective dimension of quantity, and rendered functional, not only to profit, but also to the deceptive principle of usefulness, on which we have based the counter-reform of our educational and training institutions.
If, instead, we are to cultivate critical thinking and independent thought, our education institutions must be capable activating a culture of liberty and responsibility. (Can we truly have one without the other?) The objective is to move towards cultural, inclusive innovation, keeping in mind that innovating initially means destabilizing.
Are we capable of teaching students how to become elastic, open-minded, hybrid figures, capable of building a genuine culture of complexity, and of healing the fractures between fields of knowledge, instead of perpetrating an educational system whose objectives, openly declared, are to "instruct" (aha!) and train people to be hyper-specialised technicians and mere executors of functions and rules?
The issue, as always, is educational and cultural: we have not learned to relinquish our decrepit myths, rooted in the erroneous view that still confuses complicated systems with complex systems, mechanisms with organisms. As things keep getting faster and faster, the sheer acceleration of processes has left little or no time for reflection, critical thinking, imagination or creativity, which are nourished precisely by contamination(s) between fields of knowledge, experiences, and socio-cultural landscapes. Thought, which requires time and a capacity for abstraction, makes us slow and inefficient, whereas with the aim of becoming “perfect” (machines?) -- we are staking everything on (hyper)velocity and on processes of simulation and automation. Having severed thought, we fall into Arendt’s vision of humanity enslaved by its own know-how, at the mercy of any technologically possible device, even the most ferocious. Meanwhile, with the advent and progressive tuning of artificial intelligence, a complex synthesis between man and machine, whose implications we cannot foresee, may create a new epistemological fracture.
Teaching complexity, the scientific method, critical and systemic thinking, nurtures a multidimensional kind of thinking and awareness that although data and empirical evidence are indubitably fundamental, they fail to give a complete picture of phenomena, of reality, and of the hypercomplexity of the Social and the Vital.
The (complex) organizations where young people will be employed are adaptive social systems, actual “organisms”; consequently, students must be educated (not indoctrinated!) to be capable of inhabiting and interacting with complexity, trained in unpredictability, open-minded thinking, imagining, and ultimately, in coping with the unexpected and the indetermined.
Prof. Piero Dominici is a sociologist, philosopher, educator and systems thinker. He is founder and scientific director of the International Research and Education Programme CHAOS: Complex Human Adaptive Organizations & Systems. Prof Dominici has published a book with Springer on this topic, also entitled Beyond Black Swans: Inhabiting Indeterminacy. Read more here